Expanded Reason Awards Conditions
Seventh edition (2023-2025)
Universidad Francisco de Vitoria, in collaboration with the Vatican Foundation Joseph Ratzinger-Benedict XVI, is announcing the seventh edition of the Expanded Reasons Awards, the aim of which is to recognise and promote university work that serves the truth and aspires to the advancement of man and of society.
The award recipients are university professors and researchers working in any area of knowledge, who have obtained results in the research or teaching field through scientific papers or academic programmes featuring an expanded reason approach.
According to Benedict XVI, expanded reason is defined as a way of conceiving and using reason that seeks to comprehend the full breadth of reality through a dialogue between science, philosophy and theology.
This perspective emphasises the contributions made by the different branches of science, each with their own learning methods, to knowledge as a whole. In turn, it aims to transcend the limits of each particular type of science through a broader understanding: one prompted by questions about truth, the individual, good and meaning.
To expand reason is to open it up to these four existential questions raised in philosophy and theology, through a profound appreciation for science.
It is about creating a dialogue between different disciplines “with the utmost respect for their individual methods and mutual independence, but also aware of their intrinsic unity” [1].
[1] Benedict XVI, Address to the Participants of the Fourth National Ecclesial Convention of Italy, 19 October 2006.
In contrast to reductionism of any kind (empiricism, utilitarianism, fideism, etc.), this vision advocates expanding reason to all aspects of reality, to all forms of knowledge, and to all dimensions of the individual, which also requires creating a space for the possibility of “an encounter of faith and reason, between genuine enlightenment and religion” [2]. Therefore, this entails engaging the entire person: reason and faith, science and conscience, intelligence and heart.
And in contrast to the fragmentation of knowledge and hyper-specialisation, it encourages the search for a harmonious mixture of types of knowledge. “We want to move beyond the compartmentalisation and positivism that has prevailed in university lecture halls in recent decades, to propose, from a new perspective, a vision of our disciplines that encompasses humanity, surpassing the limits of each branch of science in an endless search for meaning and wholeness” [3].
[2] Ibid., Address at the University of Regensburg: Faith, Reason and the University. Memories and Reflections, 12 September 2006.
[3] María Lacalle Noriega, En busca de la unidad del saber. Una propuesta para renovar las disciplinas académicas, revised, expanded, bilingual 2nd edition, Madrid: Editorial UFV, 2018, p. 9.
The aim of the Vatican Foundation Joseph Ratzinger-Benedict XVI is to promote the study of Theology and dialogue between Theology and culture in today’s society. To this end, it has a grant programme for PhD students in theology and organises Conferences of great cultural and scientific value in collaboration with a number of universities around the world.
The awards bestowed include the Ratzinger Prize, which rewards work by men and women —whether Catholic or not— who, through a life of scholarship, have devoted themselves fully to the Gospel, making it comprehensible for their contemporaries.
In conjunction with Universidad Francisco de Vitoria, it promotes and collaborates in the Expanded Reason Awards, which acknowledge professors’ and researchers’ efforts to expand the horizons of rationality based on a dialogue between science and disciplines and philosophy and theology.
To embody this vision in university endeavours, the Expanded Reason Awards honour work on any subject matter that creates a dialogue between a particular branch of science and philosophy and/or theology. The aim is to push each particular branch of science to the limit and to pose fundamental questions that science itself cannot answer:
This question could be posed as: What is the underlying idea of man in my discipline? Individualistic or supportive? Purely historical or open to transcendence? Genetically determined or capable of freedom? What type of man is constructed with this type of knowledge? And what type of society?
This issue could be expressed through the following key questions: Is what I teach and research true? What is the aim and limit of my branch of science and my method? What questions take me to the limits of my branch of science, which I cannot answer through it?
Questions about man and truth lead to the issue of how to act, in our scientific work and its technological applications, as well as in the way in which we lead own lives. The ethical issue always refers to the aims of each branch of science and its consequences.
In the heart of every professor and student there lies a need for meaning, both in their university endeavours and in ultimate matters.
Is what I am learning, teaching or researching worth it? How is it related to what matters to me in life? Why do I do it, and what for?
Papers that address crucial issues of our time through an expanded reason approach will be welcomed especially.
There are two award categories:
- Research category
This includes published or unpublished articles and books that scientifically address a certain issue through an expanded reason approach. The works submitted must be no more than five years old. - Teaching category
This includes university-level academic programmes (syllabuses, teaching guides, curricula, methodological proposals, etc.) and initiatives that promote a person’s comprehensive education in a certain science and thoroughly explain how the expanded reason questions fit in.
University professors and researchers of any nationality, individually or as a team, are eligible to apply for these awards (teams must specify the name of the coordinator or principal investigator).
Academic institutions and research institutes may also participate. When registering, it must be specified that the institution itself is submitting the entry, even if the application is submitted by the researchers.
If an award is granted to a team, it shall be distributed proportionally amongst the team members. If it is an entity, the entity shall be paid directly.
The awards are open to any area of knowledge: arts and humanities, experimental science, health science, social and legal science, engineering and architecture.
Four awards, for 25,000 euros each, will be granted across the two categories [4].
The winners agree to participate in the award ceremony, preceded by a seminar for UFV professors, where they will explain the main conclusions of their work. These two events will be held on consecutive days. The Institute will bear the travel and accommodation expenses.
The recipients will also have the opportunity to join the Expanded Reason Institute’s network of partners and to participate in its activities.
If the award is bestowed on a collaborative project, the coordinator or principal investigator will be in charge of representing the group.
If deemed appropriate by the jury, certain projects may be granted an honourable mention, and their authors will be invited to take part in the seminar and in the award ceremony, including travel and accommodation expenses.
[4] The award sums are subject to applicable withholdings in accordance with tax regulations.
Work may be submitted through the Expanded Reason Awards website using the form provided.
All submissions must include the following:
No more than 500 words.
This document must serve as a guide for reading the paper submitted, and must clearly outline why the paper is deemed applicable to expanded reason and how it takes the anthropological, epistemological, ethical and meaning issues into account. This document shall be particularly relevant for the jury in assessing the pertinence of the paper in relation to the aim of this competition. The text, which may have 3,000 to 8,000 words, must follow the Editorial UFV style guide.
Of the author or authors, free format.
May be submitted in Spanish, English, Italian and French. The format is free. Papers already published after 2019 are accepted.
Papers may be submitted until 21 March 2025.
In July 2025, the jury’s decision will be published on the www.razonabierta.org website
In the Research category, the following will be assessed in particular:
- The quality and accuracy of the knowledge about the specific science and the methodology inherent to the discipline.
- The timeliness and scientific, cultural and social relevance of the subject, as well as its originality.
- The inclusive approach.
- The depth of the dialogue created between the specific science and philosophy and/or theology.
- The soundness of the basis for the anthropological, epistemological, ethical and meaning issues.
- The timeliness and quality of the bibliography.
- The wording of the explanatory text, following the criteria in Point IV herein above.
In the Teaching category, the following will be assessed in particular:
- The quality, timeliness and accuracy of the knowledge about the specific science.
- The inclusive approach.
- The soundness of the basis for the anthropological, epistemological, ethical and meaning issues.
- The timeliness and quality of the bibliography.
- The clarity of the underlying approach and the pedagogical appropriateness.
The originality of the proposed learning methodologies.
The evidence of the impact on the overall education of the students. For this purpose, the projects must include some kind of method for measuring outcomes.
- Demonstrable quality and rigor in the knowledge and methodology within a particular discipline.
- Contemporary scientific, cultural and social relevance and originality of the work.
- A comprehensive approach.
- Depth of the dialogue between a particular science and philosophy and/or theology.
- The soundness of the grounding in anthropological, epistemological and ethical issues and the question of meaning.
- The relevance and quality of the bibliography.
- The rigor of the explanatory document in the terms of the criteria indicated in point 4 above.
- Demonstrable quality and rigor in the knowledge and methodology applied to a particular discipline.
- A comprehensive approach.
- The soundness of the grounding in anthropological, epistemological and ethical issues and the question of meaning.
- The relevance and quality of the bibliography.
- The clarity and coherence of the academic program and its pedagogical application.
- The originality of the proposed learning methodologies.
- Evidence of the impact on the comprehensive education of students.
By participating in this competition, the applicants accept all the conditions herein and agree to abide by the jury’s decisions, which are final.
The applicants warrant that they are the authors of the work submitted and that they have all necessary permission to submit the work in this competition.
Provided that the Scientific Committee grants its approval, the applicants agree to allow the explanatory document or the abstract of their work to be published in the Expanded Reason Digital Repository. If they wish, they can also consent to the publication of the complete work. All work published in the DEDIRA shall be protected by the Creative Commons License Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
The jury will be composed of internationally renowned professors and researchers appointed by Universidad Francisco de Vitoria and approved by the Foundation Joseph Ratzinger-Benedict XVI. The president of the Vatican Foundation Joseph Ratzinger-Benedict XVI and the rector of Universidad Francisco de Vitoria shall co-chair the jury.
The jury shall decide by a majority of the votes cast.
The awards may be declared null and void if the jury decides that the proposals received do not meet the quality requirements.
All the applicants expressly waive any right to challenge the jury’s decision.
These conditions may be modified at any time without prior notice.
The data controller is Universidad Francisco de Vitoria.
Contact details: Universidad Francisco de Vitoria. Secretaría General. Ctra. M-515 Pozuelo-Majadahonda, km 1,800; 28223, Pozuelo de Alarcón (Madrid).
Data protection officer’s contact details: dpd@ufv.es
Universidad Francisco de Vitoria will process personal data for the following purposes:
To manage your application for the Expanded Reason Awards.
To invite you to future activities organised by Universidad Francisco de Vitoria and send you information that may be of your interest, as well as to post videos and images on the university’s websites and social media, in which you may appear as a result of your participation in the university’s activities (events related to the awards, classes, conferences, etc.). The invitations and information may also be sent by electronic means (SMS, email, student portal and social media).
The legitimate basis for processing the data is the data subject’s consent, to which end such party must check the boxes created in the application form for this purpose.
The personal data will be processed during the following periods:
Until the consent granted is revoked or the data subject objects to the processing.
The data of the participants and works submitted for the awards shall be processed perpetually.
Universidad Francisco de Vitoria relies on diverse application and IT support suppliers that have access to personal data during contract performance. Universidad Francisco de Vitoria shall, at all times, have a signed data access contract in place with such parties in accordance with the requirements of Article 28 of the General Data Protection Regulation, which provides sufficient guarantees in the processing performed by these providers. Some of these providers are located outside the European Union, in which case Universidad Francisco de Vitoria requests additional guarantees, in accordance with the system established for international transfers in the General Data Protection Regulation, such as hiring providers that are certified under the European Union-United States framework agreement known as Privacy Shield (www.privacyshield.gov).
Anyone is entitled to receive information about whether their data are processed, to access their personal data, to request the rectification of any inaccurate data and, where applicable, to request the erasure of their data when, among other reasons, the data are no longer needed for the purposes for which they were gathered or if the data subject withdraws the consent granted.
In certain cases, data subjects may request that the processing of their data be restricted, in which case we shall only store them in accordance with the regulations in force.
In certain cases, data subjects may exercise the right to data portability, in which case the data will be furnished in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format to you or to a new data controller of your choice.
You have the right to withdraw the consent granted for any of the processing at any time.
To exercise your rights, you must send a written statement in this regard, signed electronically or accompanied by a photocopy of your ID document. If you are acting through a proxy, the statement must be accompanied by a sufficient power of attorney and a copy of that person’s ID document or electronic signature.
Statements must be submitted in person at the university registration office or sent by post to the address appearing in the “Contact” section of the website.
You have the right to contact our data protection officer to discuss any matters related to the processing of your personal data or the exercise of your rights pursuant to these regulations, and to file a complaint before the competent supervisory authority if you feel that you have been unable to exercise your rights in a suitable manner.
The resolution deadline is one month after receipt of your request. It may be extended two further months in light of the complexity of the request or the number of requests received.
If any of your data change, we would kindly ask you to notify us of this in writing, so that we can update your details.